PB&C, or peanut butter and chocolate, is probably my favorite flavor profile. There is just something perfect about the flavors of a reeses peanut butter cup that I love to recreate in baked goods. So what better dessert to make for my birthday than peanut butter brownies with chocolate ganache?
I previously have made this recipe from Smitten Kitchen without changing a thing. This time, I decided I really wanted a traditional peanut butter cup flavor and switched over to milk chocolate for the chips and ganache. How could these not make for a good birthday dessert?
My recipe is slightly modified from Deb’s.
To make the brownies you will need:
1/2 pound unsalted butter (2 sticks) at room temperature or a little soft
1 1/2 cups sugar
1 cup creamy peanut butter (I used old school Jif- I actually think I prefer Skippy but Jif was on sale)
2 large eggs and 1 large egg yolk
2 tsp vanilla extract
2 cups all-purpous flour
1 1/2 cups milk chocolate chips
pinch of salt
Instructions:
Preheat oven to 350 degrees. Grease a 9×13 baking pan.
Beat butter and sugar together until fluffy with an electric mixer on medium speed.
Beat in the peanut butter on high.
Add the eggs, yolk, salt, and vanilla and beat on high. I recommend cracking the eggs into a separate bowl first. That way if you drop some shell in the bowl, you can remove it before it ends up in the batter.
Reduce the mixer to low speed and slowly add in your flour. Pause to scrape sides of bowl and continue to mix until all flour is incorporated.
Stir in the chocolate chips.
Spread batter into pan, it will be thick.
Bake for 30-40 minutes. My brownies were done at 28 minutes. When you use a dark baking pan your baked goods may cook faster. Brownies are done when edges are browned and a knife or toothpick comes out clean.
Once the brownies are cooled (about 2 hours later), it is time to make the ganache! I used the recipe for Milk Chocolate Ganache from this cookbook I received as a wedding shower gift:
Usually I find ganache to be very easy to make. However, you need to be focused enough so that when you are mixing the chocolate with hot cream, your temperature is right and the ingredients blend well. If you don’t do this, you may end up with little fat droplets in your ganache (not so appetizing). After hearing the sad news on Friday, I was rushed and unfocussed so my ganache did not come out as well as I’d normally like. Retrospectively, I should have decided to start over once the ganache wasn’t right, but I was too impatient and went ahead with the batch I was making.
Ingredients for the Ganache:
10 ounces of milk chocolate chips or milk chocolate chopped (this is the type of thing where I would highly recommend weighing your ingredient)
1/2 cup (4 fluid ounces) heavy whipping cream
2 tablespoons butter, softened
Directions:
As I said above, this is pretty straightforward, but requires patience.
Put chocolate into a heatproof bowl.
Heat cream in stove just until boiling.
Pour boiled cream over chocolate and whisk together until smooth. **
Stir in butter until completely mixed. Your final product should be smooth.
Now if you have a problem with your ganache like I did, you can try to fix it without starting over. The Lindt cookbook recommends chilling half of the ganache, heating the other half over a double boiler, and then combining. Since I wasn’t in a very patient mood I tried to just fix it by mixing the entire batch over a double boiler. It worked a little bit but I still had to pick out some leftover fat droplets.
Now, hopefully you have a nice and silky smooth ganache! Spread ganache over brownies.
Once you finish, chill the brownies in fridge for 2 hours or overnight. Ganache should harden.
Cut and enjoy! I recommend cutting off the edges before serving.
Notes:
**This is where I made my mistake. I thought that the lumps in my my melted chocolate were just air bubbles. They were actually fat droplets and were not going to get whisked away. At this point I should have started over with fresh ingredients!
I think next time I’d use chocolate chunks instead of chips in the batter, just seems like a better fit.
These are very similar to blondies in texture. They’d go well with a glass of milk!
If you use this ganache recipe, you will probably have extra. I bet you didn’t know that ganache is the base of making truffles! Just refrigerate excess for a couple of hours or overnight. Once chilled, scoop teaspoons worth of ganache and roll into balls. Now you have truffles!
You could even roll these in cocoa powder, jimmies (yes, I call them jimmies) or chopped almonds to dress them up.
Have you ever made a baking mistake because you were in a rush?
Yes! If I’m on the phone! Whenever I’m on the phone while I’m trying to bake, I can so easily make a mistake! I can leave an entire ingredient out! So now I just make the choice. Phone call or baked good. It’s a no brainer for which one wins…!!!!!!
I love this recipe! I think the chocolate ganache on top is the perfect balance for all the peanut butter. I guess that’s how they came up with the “PEANUT BUTTER CUP”!!!! They SO knew what they were doing! And personally, I love the ganache anyway. Some think it’s way too rich or too sweet or too heavy. But there’s no such word as “too” in my baking vocabulary!!
Thanks Lauren!
Haha I am totally with you. The brownie isn’t really very rich so the ganache is a good touch to it.
These were amazing Lauren! Good job and Happy Birthday!!!! xo
Yes I have make many mistakes when baking . I’m lazy and instead of measuring my flour and putting it in a seperate bowl I measure it out of the bag and put it in the mixer and then for get how many cups I’ve put in. So I have to start over. These brownies sound de-lish I love chocolate and peanut butter!!!!!!!!!!
Oh I have definitely had problems with miscounting!
oooooooooh i love these!
These look awesome! I love anything PB&C!! Today I made a huge mistake while in a hurry (not for baking, but it still hurt!) … I sliced my finger with a big chopping knife! Woops.
oh no, that does not sound fun!
Hi there,
Thanks for the sweet comment on my site!
I’m really likin’ your site! I love the photos of you while you’re cookin. Do you take those or your hubby?
🙂
Thanks!! The Husband takes those photos:-)
ahh yum these look so good! Love you!
wow, those brownies look amazing, i may have to steal the recipe.
my baking mistakes usually happen when i try not to over bake things. (then i underbake.) it’s a skill i haven’t quite learned how to master 🙂
haha I must admit that I hate when I overbake things and would almost prefer they be underbaked!
YES!!!!!! OMG GIRL THERES ARE REDICULOUS!! ❤
They really are… I have some stored in my freezer for the Jewish holidays and I still want to eat them:-) Let me know if you try them!
I loved the ganache truffles
Peanut Butter, ewww
one day you are going to like it, i am convinced!
Hey Lauren,
I just made these brownnies. I can’t wait to taste them. I was afraid of the ganache , but I took it slow and I think it came out. I put the extra in the frig. to make the truffles.
Thanks so much. Love the cook book!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
oh i am so glad- let me know how they taste!!! by the way, if you have any extras they freeze very well.
Wow those look delicious!! And yes I HATE making mistakes when I’m baking. I get so excited about what I’m baking so if I ever mess up it is so frustrating! Haha. I just found your blog though and I LOVE it!! I love dessert more than anything 🙂
thank you so much!
[…] butter as a main ingredient. I haven’t baked with almond butter before, I am more of a die-hard peanut butter lover, but I do enjoy it for variety. This Food &Wine cookbook actually has a ton of great recipes […]
[…] if you have some baking experience. I actually thought the ganache was much easier than the last time I made one (that could be because I was relaxed and not rushed, […]
Best flavor combo for sure! Those look DELISH!
[…] to THE peanut butter and chocolate item. You have seen my fan favorite cookie bar and the peanut butter brownies with chocolate ganache. So have my friends. Both items were a hit, so I knew when it came to my peanut butter […]
[…] if you have some baking experience. I actually thought the ganache was much easier than the last time I made one (that could be because I was relaxed and not rushed, […]